Updated:
Original:

Omarion Attempts to Define R&B: An Unintentional Lesson in Melody

One simple comment from Omarion led to us deconstructing an entire genre.
DJBooth_logo2x

You know those things in life that you’re so familiar with, you never think to question their origin, composition or meaning? Example: what the hell does “scot-free” mean? We know it means getting away with something without consequence... but why does it mean that? What makes it mean that?

The arts are subject to the same sort of familiarity-fueled ignorance as many of our daily idioms and descriptors (I still don’t understand why anyone would let a bull in a china shop), and I recently received a thorough schooling in melody and R&B from an unlikely source—R&B veteran, Omarion.

Okay, it wasn’t actually Omarion who taught me about these things, it was Dr. Scott D. Paulin, a professor of Musicology at Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois, but Omarion was the catalyst.

Allow me to explain.

In a recent interview with Noisey, Omarion was asked how he felt about the current state of R&B, to which he gave the following response:

"I'm going to be honest with you, there are some wack songs out but there's some great melodies. A great melody can save a song from not having powerful lyrics because it just rings in your head. So anytime there's melody, that's what Omarion considers rhythm and blues."

At first glance, this is a pretty standard answer. It’s the kind of vague diplomacy that artists of Omarion’s caliber usually stick to; it addresses their gripe in a general sense without calling out any artists by name, potentially risking future collaboration or tour partners.

But while the rest of us would be stuck on the fact that Omarion just referred to himself in the third person (amazing), our editor-in-chief Z, being the scrupulous man that he is, had a much more inquisitive takeaway.

“Anytime there’s melody, that’s what Omarion considers rhythm and blues.” That statement begs the question, “Is it even 'music' without melody?” Can R&B music exist without melody, which is, by definition, “a rhythmic succession of single tones organized as an aesthetic whole”?

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

am-world-roundup-16x9-917

5 New Albums You Need to Hear This Week

Lil Nas X, Tems, Tion Wayne, Injury Reserve, and Unusual Demont all have albums you need this week on Audiomack.

BOTWWorld150

Maxo Kream, Ari Lennox & Syd: Best of the Week

Maxo Kream, Ari Lennox, Syd, and more had the best new songs on Audiomack this week.

am-world-roundup-16x9-910

5 New Albums You Need to Hear This Week

Baby Keem, María Isabel, Deb Never, Yeat, and Tony Seltzer all have albums you need this week on Audiomack.

After our own exhaustive research online, we turned to Dr. Paulin for his expert insight and the professor’s response shined a whole new light on a genre we once believed we were experts on.

“It depends what you mean by ‘melody’,” Dr. Paulin explained. “Melody doesn't necessarily just mean a tune, which implies singability and regularity of structure; any intentional (and possibly non-intentional) organization of pitches can, strictly speaking, be a melody.”

The professor provided multipleexamples of music that was not particularly melodic in the standard sense of the word, and referenced Bob Dylan’s “Subterranean Homesick Blues” as “practically a zero-degree of melody,” noting, “ but no-one (I don't think) would argue that it's not music.”

So by the most basic definition of the word, everything that we collectively agree is music is comprised of melody, in a technical sense. But what about the more widely agreed upon usage of the term? Can you make hip-hop or R&B without singability and regularity of structure?

According to Dr. Paulin, “In hip-hop, the vocal might not be a 'sung melody' but it still has contour in addition to rhythm, and it's usually embedded in a sonic context that is unambiguously ‘musical.’” As for rhythm and blues, Dr. Paulin says, “it's harder to imagine non-melodic R&B since expressivity of vocal melody is, I think, nearly a defining characteristic of R&B as a genre,” but admits that, “...I'm sure there are instances that push this to the limit as well.”

While defining what is or isn’t “music” is still somewhat subjective—Dr. Paulin ended his explanation by stating, “Probably it's best to think broadly about ‘music’ as encompassing anything that both the creator and the listener agree to identify as ‘music’”—R&B specifically, in any known incarnation anyway, must contain melody.

Basically, by the standard definition of "melody" inherent in R&B, it would be impossible to craft a non-melodic R&B record, effectively meaning that, yes, all R&B music contains melody, aside from some experimental outsiders that may or may not even exist.  

I never expected Omarion's personal definition of R&B to bring me closer to understanding melody, but here we are, and I’m glad it happened.

***

By Brent Bradley. Follow him on Twitter.

Related

Rihanna, 2016

5 Songs Defined Rihanna’s Decade

Rihanna, in the 2010s, became a genre-bending superstar.

DJBooth_logo2x

An Ode to Sway, a True Hip-Hop Gatekeeper

Let's take a moment to appreciate a man who's helped push hip-hop forward for over two decades.

DJBooth_logo2x

Two Miles Per Hour: An Ode To "Drive Testing" Albums

For myself and many others, there’s no better way to ingest a musical offering.

DJBooth_logo2x

"Xanax Is Not the Wave": An Open Letter to Lil Pump

From someone who knows first-hand the dangers of addiction: trust me.

DJBooth_logo2x

An Ode to Mase's 'Harlem World,' My Very First Hip-Hop Album

For better or worse, Mase’s debut album was my introduction to hip-hop.

DJBooth_logo2x

The Lesson All Artists Can Learn From Ja Rule's Post Hip-Hop Career

Just because an artist isn’t in the spotlight doesn’t mean they’re not making moves.