I Prayed to Gotti: Why ‘American Gangster’ Is JAY-Z’s Hustler Masterpiece

By digging into the darkness of his past, Hov created a drug-dealing epic.

"Man, there’s nothing wrong with telling ghost stories. We need them. We love them. We love these things..” —Pusha-T

You never forget the imagery of a woman being force-fed dirty dollar bills once hearing “D’Evils.” It‘s a gruesome illustration, vividly disgusting, but crossing the line of reality into a scene you would expect to play out in a surrealistic mafia movie.

In a song about corruption and the poison of greed, I‘ve always found “I never prayed to God, I prayed to Gotti” to be the most ear-grabbing lyric. It‘s a detail so tiny that most rappers would omit this spine-shivering blasphemy. But not Jay. He wanted listeners to know the only higher power was not the ruler of heaven; it was men who conquered the streets.

Living life by Gotti’s commandments depicts the kind of fellow whose life resembles Tony Montana and not Tony! Toni! Toné! Jay didn’t need to show off Dracos and run off on plugs to make listeners feel the authenticity of his stories; the nuances sprinkled into his lyricism crafted a portrait only Hov could paint. These small, unobtrusive descriptions make Jay’s underworldly depictions feel authentic. They create something real in the most surreal way. Greed, pleasure, and regret all give Reasonable Doubt a pulse, a mafioso album built on more than a persona exaggeration.

We feel this pulse whenever Jay decides to revisit his past as a drug-dealing hustler, rewinding memories instead of constructing fables. I’m skeptical about the 92 bricks, one of Jay’s most questionable legends, but it’s a rare myth in a sea of respected validity.

When Jigga opened Pusha-T’s email containing “Drug Dealers Anonymous” he hit rewind, and his response was perfect. “WTF? Why you taking me to a dark place?” he replied, giving us a sense that a chord was struck. The reaction was triggering. Memories that were buried were starting to surface. Memories are why American Gangster isn‘t Kingdom Come; the inescapable past guided Hov to a place he couldn’t tap into when searching for the voice and sound of his prosperous present.

The backstory behind the album: JAY-Z couldn’t watch Denzel Washington portray the legendary Frank Lucas without drawing comparisons to his past life. Inspiration surged through him, a desire to represent the hustler in audio form. Memories of his days dealing drugs are embedded into his mental muscles like riding a bicycle. This was the period in his life when he learned to store all his lyrics without writing them, but he also stored all the unlawful activities that unfolded while he was crafting his style of pad-less writing. Only in hip-hop can the hustler survive the trials and tribulations that are meant to bring his downfall. But Jay went where the previous gangsters and mobsters couldn’t. Being able to look back allowed him to make an ode to the past, present, and future hustlers of America.

Post-retirement, Jay has never sounded more alive than on “Blue Magic,” the first single from American Gangster. Embedded in his boastful tone and swagger-filled delivery is the elation of a middle-aged man retelling stories from his quarterback glory days. Tapping into dope boy nostalgia, his three verses moonwalk through Reagan-era kitchens and blocks flooded with crack vials, junkies and crooked cops. Hov didn’t sound like a new rapper, but an old one who had found his fire. The jaunty yet sinister Pharrell production is equally as potent. This was an exciting release, the kind of foreshadowing single that made fans believe the real return of JAY-Z was forthcoming.

“Blue Magic” is an epic teaser, but the entire body of work is why American Gangster has a lasting place in Jay’s discography. The idea was to build the album around specific scenes of the movie, each song being a different point in the rise and fall that unfolded in the film. But Jay seamlessly weaves his life and the film‘s plot together. At various points in the album, it‘s unclear who is who—that’s how close the resemblance is.

“Pray” introduces impeccable storytelling, the genesis of a hustler born due to the poverty of his environment. “American Dreamin’” continues to build around this character, bringing us into the mental tension, fear, and rush of entering into the unlawful life of a corner boy. “Pray” and “American Dreamin‘” alone could make for a short story script. This is the caliber of dexterous attention to detail Hov has employed across his career.



Stepping Into Cico P’s Texas

East Texas native Cico P makes a case for not sleeping on his city. He breaks down his sound for Audiomack World.


Juls’ Journey Through the Diaspora

Juls helped build up Afrobeats from a footnote in global pop music into a full and highly-cited chapter. He breaks it down for Audiomack World.


Don Toliver, Tame Impala & 5an: Best of the Week

Don Toliver, Tame Impala, 5an, and more, all had the best new songs on Audiomack this week.

By “No Hook," the character vanishes and JAY-Z turns to autobiographical soul-spilling. He sounds possessed—like a switch was pushed—vomiting all these emotions that have arrested his soul since jumping off the porch. Each line hits, each bar more striking than the last; any hook would’ve disrupted the stream-of-consciousness.  

Compare me to trappers, I'm more Frank Lucas than Ludacris / And Luda's my dude, I ain't trying to diss / Like Frank Lucas is cool, but I ain't trying to snitch / I'ma follow the rules no matter how much time I'ma get

"No Hook" is an example of how Jay‘s brilliance ruins the concept but he still attempts to intertwine the film and the album‘s concept. Ludacris has nothing to do with selling crack in the 70s but the line hits so hard it begs for inclusion. Despite being removed from his past life, Jay isn’t distant from the moral code. Continuing with the theme of being more trapper than rapper, the entire first verse of “Roc Boys” is dedicated to the championing of hustler motifs―the connects to the customer, duffle bags and shoe boxes. Over the most elegant horns, he celebrates.

It’s this ecstatic enjoyment that makes the first line in “Sweet” so harrowing: “Still there’s pain, If I would have grew up to be a doctor, my nephew would have grew up to do the same.” He is showing us that he is a role model who knows his imperfect life is both sweet and bitter. He weighs the internal conflict, an inner-plight that is rarely articulated when showcasing the layers and complexity of dealing drugs. All this money and fast living don‘t affect just one person―entire families are impacted by the weight of these decisions.

Sounds of ‘70s jazz and soul score the chronicles of the hustler. You feel the dust from the records, a sound that feels old, dated, but like the soul samples that make The Blueprint radiate, the lush bed of sounds adds a necessary coating to American Gangster. Jay couldn’t make a modern-sounding album and still deliver views from the crack era.

I never forgave Diddy for his horrendous contributions to In My Lifetime, Vol. 1, but he redeemed himself with the five songs he co-produced with LV & Sean C for American Gangster. Gorgeous instrumentation paired with the dirty dealings unfolding in the underworld is a union Jay hasn’t mastered since. Constructing the album with so much foresight is why it feels like a complete body of work; everything moves in a cohesive flow. There are no sore thumbs or outcast records—“I Know” isn’t completely necessary but it adds a bit of fun before the fall.

“Success” is home to musings with a philosophical Nas, “Ignorant Shit” is home to a blackout tag team with Beans, rap disparagers are berated on “Bad Guy,” and the prison cell closes on the album closer “Fallin‘.” Each record reveals a motivated Shawn Carter who uses the surge of inspiration to find the footing fans wanted when he ended his brief retirement.

Jay never lost “it,” he just needed to find the right subject matter. This is the heartbeat of American Gangster, the survivalist who lived to tell the tale. A man who can tell you about the grimmest details, the highest highs and the lowest lows, all while being an image of how you can take the hustler‘s practice and conquer legal fields with the same mentality. 

American Gangster will never have the acclaim of The Blueprint or The Black Album, but it is Jay‘s best project since The Black Album.

I understand why Hov doesn’t want to base his entire career on rewinding and reminiscing. There‘s Basquiats hanging in his kitchen instead of crack hovering over the stove. It’s still a dark place, though, a world where the pain outweighs the beauty. 

Pressure makes diamonds, and out of that darkness, JAY-Z continues to pull out light.  American Gangster is his darkest light since Reasonable Doubt and the best representation of the hustler‘s tale. 

By Yoh, aka Frank Yohcus, aka @Yoh31



Why Kanye West's '808s & Heartbreak' Is a Masterpiece

Yoh delivers a testament to the greatness of an album that will stand the test of time.


I Don't Pop Molly: Jay Z's Almost 50 & Staying Relevant

Jay's old enough to be a grandfather, can he really have the next song of the summer by working with Future?


Ego Death: How JAY-Z Found His Most Vulnerable Voice on '4:44'

Sometimes, the biggest obstacle is the man in the mirror.


Meet the Brooklyn Soul Band Who JAY-Z, Kendrick & Kid Cudi All Sampled to Make Magic

You've heard the Menahan Street Band, even if you've never listened to them.


A New JAY-Z Album Is (Probably) Coming

At 47 years of age and with 12 solo albums under his belt, how much rapping does Hov have left in him?


JAY-Z Rapping Over Immaculate Horns, an Absurdly Detailed Investigation

Whether it's a sax, trumpet or trombone, JAY-Z has a history of rapping over production with incredible horns.